Shortly after revealing the pin, Alby's smirk would disappear. He expected that to clear everything up, Colten was supposed to gasp or something and then he was going to know for sure that he'd been lying. But the reaction he got ended up having an opposite effect. Alby would squint again, frowning and looking confused. Colten must have been ridiculously good at lying. Unless he was telling the truth.
After narrowing his eyes, he'd blink them. "You seriously don't recognize this thing?" He was feeling a little more open to the idea that perhaps Colten was being completely honest. "But... If it really wasn't you then how does that even work? How do you explain something like that? You think it was a shapeshifter or something?"
Alby decided to humor Colten for the time being, but still wasn't completely on board with the idea that he was telling the truth.
After narrowing his eyes, he'd blink them. "You seriously don't recognize this thing?" He was feeling a little more open to the idea that perhaps Colten was being completely honest. "But... If it really wasn't you then how does that even work? How do you explain something like that? You think it was a shapeshifter or something?"
Alby decided to humor Colten for the time being, but still wasn't completely on board with the idea that he was telling the truth.