It wasn't so much her family that bothered Fatima as it was the circumstances surrounding their death, but she did appreciate his skipping over family talk, so she didn't say anything more on that topic. She was curious what it was like with just one parent. Though she knew that most people would've had only two parents and even single parents, the young horseman had never really interacted with any families other than the cult, which would be considered rather large for a family.
She nodded at his comments on the New Year's Party, which she also didn't intend to get much into. Fatima had only really brought that up as part of gauging timing. She had definitely not enjoyed being human, although it hadn't so much been her powers gone missing that had upset her, but more all the other things that humans found necessary. She didn't think she'd ever forget how awful it had been to sleep. "Yes, well, apparently there's lots of things that non-humans don't really realise count as powers. Different biology and stuff. I think it probably affected people who only had their powers nulled the least, actually."
Fatima giggled along with Taffy. His bright personality was somewhat infectious, and she was not gonna stop calling him by his accidental nickname in her head. She had a feeling he wouldn't mind even if she said it out loud really. When the boy started mentioning people he'd met, she wondered if she knew them. She didn't recall meeting any goblins, and there were plenty of nice ghost girls. She wasn't even put off by his meeting another Horseman, except...
She looked suspiciously at him when he said other Horseman. At first, Fatima thought he meant other than her and just assumed he'd heard it mentioned, but why would he ask if she knew about them if he knew she was one? And if he'd meant more than one, well he hadn't said that.
Taking in his age, his circumstances, Fatima felt suddenly uneasy. Yes there were other horsemen here, from other sets, and she'd met them. But someone so young made her think the cult was somehow active again, and that was just deeply unsettling to the girl. She was struck speechless for a moment, not knowing what to say. Her discomfort and slight beginnings of fear would be plainly visible on her face, in contrast to her easy chatter of just seconds before.